Toilet Repair & Replacement
Toilet Repair & Replacement in Pinetop-Lakeside & Show Low
Toilet Repair & Replacement in Pinetop-Lakeside & Show Low
Running Toilet? Leaking Base? Fixed Right.
Toilet repairs and full replacements for homes and cabins. Internal parts, wax rings, supply lines, or complete swap. From $125.
Licensed & Insured, ROC#342551
Flat-Rate Pricing
2-Year Warranty
Transparent Pricing
Toilet Repair & Replacement Pricing
Two options based on what your toilet needs. Most running toilets are a parts fix. Cracked bowls, rocking toilets, or old units get a full swap.
Toilet Repair
$125-$175
Internal parts replacement
- Diagnose the issue
- Fill valve, flapper, or flush valve replacement
- Supply line or handle replacement
- Test flush cycle and check for leaks
- Full cleanup
Full Toilet Replacement
$225-$325
Complete toilet swap
- Remove old toilet
- New wax ring and closet bolts
- Install and level new toilet
- Connect supply line
- Test flush cycle, check for leaks
- Old toilet removal and full cleanup
Prices are for labor. You supply the toilet or I source it at cost.
Warning Signs
Signs Your Toilet Needs Attention
Running Constantly
A toilet that won’t stop running usually means the fill valve or flapper is failing. Wastes water and drives up your bill until it’s fixed.
Rocking or Unstable
If the toilet rocks when you sit down, the wax ring or flange has likely failed. Left alone, this can cause water damage to the subfloor.
Cracks in Bowl or Tank
A cracked toilet bowl or tank can’t be repaired. Replacement is the only fix. Even hairline cracks can leak and worsen over time.
How It Works
Four Steps to a Working Toilet
1
Tell Me What’s Happening
Use my price calculator. Describe the issue: running, leaking, rocking, or needing a full replacement.
2
Get Your Price
Flat-rate quote based on repair or replacement. Price confirmed before work starts. No hourly billing.
3
I Fix or Replace It
Parts swapped or full toilet replaced. Wax ring, supply line, and bolts all handled. Tested and leak-checked before I leave.
4
Photo Proof
Before-and-after photos. 2-year workmanship warranty on all toilet repairs and replacements.
While I’m There
Popular Bathroom Add-Ons
Angle Stop Replacement
Replace old gate-style shutoff valves with modern quarter-turn valves while I’m already behind the toilet.
From $75
Bathroom Faucet Replacement
New bathroom faucet installed in the same visit. One trip, two upgrades.
From $125
Grab Bar Installation
Safety grab bars mounted securely into studs. Commonly added during bathroom work.
From $75
Real Reviews
What Homeowners Say
★★★★★
“Johnathan of ARC property Services responded on time as promised. He is very amiable and easy to to deal with. He repaired & troubleshot a leaking sink valve. He seems to be skilled in a variety of handyman services. He was upfront with the price of repairs.”
review ✔
★★★★★
“Jonathan is the man, he’s earned my highest recommendation! Will be going to him for all future needs, big and small! If you’re looking for a friendly and transparent handyman, he is your guy, bottom line!
We purchased new condo as is and it was in need of lots of work. He handled our plumbing needs (kitchen sink plumbed wrong, kitchen and bathroom faucet replacements), appliance needs (dishwasher was backfilling and getting flooded, water heater had active leak),…”
review ✔
★★★★★
“I’m extremely pleased with everything regarding my experience with Jonathon and ARC Property Services. I needed five safety grab bars installed in the bathroom of my elderly, disabled father’s summer retreat house in Lakeside (three in his shower and two on a wall next to the toilet), and he did an exceptional job….”
review ✔
Questions
Toilet Repair & Replacement FAQ
Toilet repair (internal parts like fill valve, flapper, flush valve, handle) starts at $125-$175. A full toilet replacement runs $225-$325. Prices are for labor only, confirmed before work starts. You supply the toilet or I source it at cost.
If the issue is a running toilet, weak flush, or leaking handle, a repair is usually all you need. If the bowl or tank is cracked, the base is rocking on a failed wax ring, or the toilet is 20+ years old and constantly needing fixes, replacement is more cost-effective long term.
Most internal repairs take 30-45 minutes. A full toilet replacement, including removing the old toilet, replacing the wax ring, setting the new toilet, connecting the supply line, and testing, typically takes 1-2 hours.
I remove the old toilet, replace the wax ring and closet bolts, set and level the new toilet, connect the supply line, test the flush cycle, check for leaks at the base and supply connection, and clean up the work area. Old toilet removal and disposal included.
Yes. A failed wax ring is one of the most common reasons a toilet rocks or leaks at the base. I pull the toilet, replace the wax ring (or install a wax-free gasket), reset the toilet, and test for leaks. This is included in a full replacement and can also be done as a standalone repair.
Yes. I serve both Pinetop-Lakeside and Show Low. Same flat-rate pricing, same 2-year warranty, no travel surcharge.
Toilet Giving You Trouble?
Get It Fixed
Get It Fixed
Fast and Right
Tell me what’s happening. Flat-rate price, no surprises, 2-year warranty on all work.
Or call directly: (480) 427-0405